*I believe in free will because I don't see much benefit to believing in fate. Do I believe that many of our choices are constrained due to environment, biology, society and other limitations? Absolutely I do. But I believe this choice: to type paoetjpaw instead of "hi Raven", is mine. My will chose that. What help is it to me if I believe it was fate or pre-ordained by the Universe? If I do something wrong, however, no-free-will becomes "not-my-fault". This is a bad thing for society in its current state. You can scan someone's brain 'til the power runs out and you won't find what caused a murderer to kill their victim three months ago at 2:58pm. In short, it's currently not a good thing to promote a no-free-will stance. If you want to believe it *personally*, go ahead... but I don't see a benefit to society or to myself: even if this free will i think I have is illusionary and I'm instead pre-programmed by Time or Fate or God or Nature or the Cosmos to make every single choice I make in life...* ...believing I have no choice will CHANGE the results - quite dramatically so and not in a good way. Mind you, I _accept_ most things are out of my control. But: critically: *some* things are in my control. == A blip showing the thought originated before my conscious awareness of it took place doesn't invalidate free will.* You accept that as evidence, as an "is"? Go for it. Your choice. Unless you don't have a choice. I do. == *FREE WILL: The ability to make a choice between options or outside of options. Kenneth Udut's definition. == You're presented with options a, b, c, d, e. Those are my choices. But i have choices beyond those choices. == It's a combination of factors. I'm not in control of it all. But that which is presented to me, plus a desire/will/whatever to go into a "whatever I feel like" direction, is mine. Is it fair or equal among peoples? I have no idea. == I don't assume universals. I can go by what "seems true enough" for me, fold in whatever evidence I find acceptable and believable and reasonable and say, "Seems true enough for me". But for me to declare "This is so for all"? I can't do that. I'm not in everybody's head. ==